The philosophical analysis of reinhart p. a. dozy's history of i̇slamic works (example İsmail Fenni, Manastirli İsmail Hakki, Filibeli Ahmet Hilmi)

In Dozy's "History of Islam" his statements about Islam and Muslims have many contradictory expressions, scientifically and philosophically. However, while this situation was considered normal by some thinkers in our country, it was extensively criticized by some nationalist and Islamist thinkers and it was felt the need to write rejections to these ideas. Abdullah Cevdet's translation of Dozy's book and the excessive praise he made against this book provoked Islamist and nationalist thinkers such as İsmail Fenni Ertuğrul, Ahmet Hilmi from Filibeli and İsmail Hakkı from Manastir. In our thesis, we tried to examine the purpose of the criticism of these thinkers, what philosophical and scientific methods they try to do and their criticism to Dozy.