Theses supervised by Doç. Dr. Mine Pınar Gözen Ercan

10 theses · Hacettepe University

Master'sOpen AccessEN

Liberal theories of self-determination: Towards peaceful settlement of self-determination disputes

The right to self-determination has stood the test of the time and is still a topic of academic discussion even though the decolonization process is thought to have ended long ago. Today's debates on self-determination are largely focused on what justifies a group's right to self-determination and under what conditions such claims are regarded to be legitimate beyond the decolonization context. After scrutinizing the history of the self-determination concept and examining relevant international legal instruments promulgated during the United Nations era, this thesis evaluates the mainstream liberal theories of self-determination. Upon finding that the Remedial Right Theory does not rest upon morally acceptable philosophical foundations, this thesis suggests a revision of the remedial right paradigm in order to improve it by eliminating the requirement for a moral threshold that the group has to endure before being able to exercise its right to external self-determination.

PeaceUnited NationsSelf-determination+5
Selçuk Ruscuklu
Hacettepe University · Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü
2019
00
Master'sOpen AccessEN

The non-participation of ASEAN countries in the International Criminal Court: A constructivist perspective

The establishment of the International Criminal Court (ICC) was celebrated by many as international criminal justice is seen as entering into a new phase of development and anti-impunity norms being formally institutionalized. The ICC is tasked with prosecuting individuals who are accused of perpetrating genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes, and crimes of aggression. The ICC, which derives its powers and jurisdiction pursuant to the 1998 Rome Statute, is the only permanent and independent international criminal court in the international system. However, except for Cambodia, the Member States of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) are reluctant to be a part of the ICC which indicate a contestation of the norms of the ICC by the ASEAN Member States. According to the social constructivist theory, shared ideas and norms impact states' decision in a socially constructed lenses of the world. In particular, ASEAN's norms are said to be the sovereignty of states and non-interference in domestic matters as reflected in the "ASEAN Way". The purpose of this paper is to analyze the different level of participations in the ICC by the ASEAN Member States, in particular Cambodia, Malaysia, Philippines and Myanmar through contestation based on their identity.

ASEAN countriesSocial constructionInternational Criminal Court+4
Aufa Radzi
Hacettepe University · Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü
2019
00
Master'sOpen AccessEN

The European Union and "Asylum shopping": A comparative analysis

Throughout history, people have moved from one place to another either individually or in groups due to various reasons, making migration movements common and widespread. Among migrants, refugees—who are defined as forced migrants uprooted by fear of persecution, conflicts and violence—have a particular place since refugee protection is a multi-faceted issue affecting countries and regions. Europe, and the European Union (EU) in particular, had previously encountered mass migration movements. Nevertheless, the ongoing refugee protection crisis—which started in 2011 following the turmoil in the Middle East and North African countries and peaked in 2015—has turned into an unprecedented humanitarian crisis. Although the EU tried to respond to the protection needs of asylum seekers reaching its territory under the framework of the Common European Asylum System (CEAS), it has failed to properly manage the crisis. As a result of this, the inherent deficiencies of the CEAS have also become apparent. In this vein, the main objective of this thesis is to analyse the issue of asylum shopping—a significant problem of the EU in the field of asylum and migration—and to determine its extent and underlying reasons with a focus on the recent refugee protection crisis. To this end, four EU Member States—namely Greece, Germany, Hungary and Sweden—are selected as representative cases, and their asylum policies and practices are compared and contrasted. Based on such analysis, this thesis concludes that there are vast differences among the asylum policies and practices of the EU Member States, and due to the failure of the EU in ensuring complete harmonisation, asylum shopping problem has continued during the recent crisis.

GermanyEuropean UnionHungary+6
Vildan Taştemel
Hacettepe University · Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü
2019
00
Master'sOpen AccessEN

Legal aspects of protection provided within the responsibility to protect framework

Although it has been almost 15 years after the adoption of the Responsibility to Protect (R2P) with the World Summit Outcome Document under Paragraphs 138 and 139, the implementation of the principle still raises controversy. Legality of coercive methods involving the use of force or the implementation phase underlies these discussions about the principle and disrupts the normative evolution of the concept. In this sense, it is necessary to highlight and enrich other methods under R2P framework whose legality is rather uncontested. This thesis, which critically approaches to the scope of R2P, examines and evaluates the legality of the tools under the principle in depth by addressing both peaceful and coercive measures in order to ensure a consistent implementation strategy. In this regard, in order to see the acceptability and success of the methods in R2P practice, Kenya and Guinea cases—which are commonly referred to as successful R2P implementations—as well as Libya and the Ivory Coast cases—which are examples of the implementation of the controversial measure of military intervention—are examined. In order to understand the negative criticisms to R2P, the assumptions of TWAIL and Feminist International Relations (IR) theory are utilized. In the light of the findings obtained by examining the legality of these tested methods, this thesis argues that enriching and deepening the peaceful elements in the toolbox of R2P with the participation of a variety of actors would help an undisputed implementation of the principle and contribute to the removal of the obstacles before R2P's normative development.

Use of forceResponsibility to protectProtection measures+1
Selin Kul
Hacettepe University · Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü
2020
00
Master'sOpen AccessEN

A critical analysis of the united nations human rights council within the framework of the responsibility to protect

Three cornerstone initiatives which were the result of series of works of the United Nations (UN) for the wellbeing of peoples, the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), the United Nations Human Rights Council (HRC) and the principle of Responsibility to Protect (R2P) were born out of the need for "a more peaceful, prosperous and just world" in the 21st century. Placing the complementary relationship between these three initiatives at its center, this thesis focuses on the role that can be played by the HRC in the implementation of R2P. In order to understand this role, it takes SDG16 as a common framework for R2P implementation especially at the level of Pillars 1 and 2. As being directly related with human rights and human rights institutions, the success of SDG16 is arguably contingent upon the well-functioning of the HRC. In questioning the impact of the HRC on R2P's implementation, it is important to determine the contributions and shortcomings in the practices of the HRC as well as its mechanisms and procedures. To this end, the thesis adopts the method of case study, and comparatively analyses the implementation of R2P in the cases of the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), Libya and Syrian Arab Republic vis-à-vis the actions of the HRC with regard to these cases. Following from this, from an implementation point of view, this thesis argues that the HRC can play a role in the upholding of Pillar 1 and Pillar 2 responsibilities under R2P at the state and international levels in a way to contribute to the achievement of SDG 16, and accordingly, it can help to devise an early response in cases of imminent threats of atrocity crimes without the need for UN Security Council authorization.

European Commission of CivilrightsUnited NationsResponsibility to protect+4
Buşra Küçük
Hacettepe University · Institute of Graduate Studies in Social Sciences
2021
00
Master'sOpen AccessEN

Prevention of mass atrocities through the responsibility to protect: A comparison of the cases of Kenya and Guinea

Although the Responsibility to Protect (R2P) populations from mass atrocity crimes was unanimously adopted under Paragraphs 138 and 139 of the 2005 World Summit Outcome Document, in inconsistencies in implementation shows that the rhetoric has not materialized into practice yet. While the use of force and the question of sovereignty were still at the core of the debates surrounding R2P, mass atrocity prevention was put forward as the novelty of the norm by its proponents. In this respect, the track record of R2P implies that a successful mass atrocity prevention strategy is necessary in order to achieve successful prevention. Taking this into consideration, this thesis aims to determine the requirements for successful mass atrocity prevention. Accordingly, it suggests a sustainable prevention framework by examining the evolution of mass atrocity prevention and related strategies. To this end, it utilizes the theory of "Localization" to reveal alternative actors outside the United Nations Security Council—such as the African Union and Economic Community of West African States—that can lead the prevention strategy. In this regard, the cases of Kenya and Guinea—which are widely recognized as successful cases of mass atrocity prevention in the R2P literature—are studied in order to analyze the prevention strategies as well as the roles played by the actors in practice. Accordingly, the comparative analysis of the two cases is used to determine the requirements for a successful prevention strategy. In the light of this, this thesis argues that successful prevention of mass atrocities requires a sustainable strategy—in line with the direct and structural prevention tools—to be implemented under the leadership of the responsible regional and sub-regional organizations

Organization of African UnityEconomic Community of West African StatesGuinea+3
Ezgi Nur Koç
Hacettepe University · Institute of Graduate Studies in Social Sciences
2021
00
Master'sOpen AccessEN

Regional refugee protection: A comparison of Europe and the middle east

By displacing more than half of the country's pre-war population, the conflict in the Syrian Arab Republic has become the catalyst for one of the biggest humanitarian and refugee crises of our time. The flow of more than 5.6 million people forced to leave their homeland has directly affected two regions: Europe and the Middle East. In order to enrich and fill certain gaps in the literature, this thesis provides an analysis of the legal framework of refugee protection from a regional perspective. By focusing on the case of people fleeing the Syrian Arab Republic, it evaluates the respective legal frameworks of the two regions and critically examines the legal grounds for protection therein. Moreover, by undertaking country case studies from both regions, this thesis also highlights the intricacies and shortcomings of the respective regional frameworks as reflected in the contradictory policies and stances of Germany, Hungary, Lebanon and Saudi Arabia toward refugees. It argues that the refugee protection frameworks of Europe and the Middle East are the antithesis of each other. In Europe, we can observe a well-developed and deep-rooted regional cooperation, more or less harmonised norms and institutions whereas the Middle East is characterised by the lack of legal foundations and norms of refugee protection with weak institutions and strong state sovereignty. However, in light of the protection outcomes for refugees fleeing the Syrian Arab Republic, both regions seem to have failed in terms of efficient responsibility sharing and adequate response to the needs of refugees.

ArabsEuropeanConservation+7
Petra Fruzsina Csorba
Hacettepe University · Institute of Graduate Studies in Social Sciences
2019
00
Master'sOpen AccessEN

Intervention by invitation within the responsibility to protect framework

The Responsibility to Protect (R2P) was introduced as a response to Kofi Annan's plea to resolve the paradox of illegal humanitarian interventions versus inaction by the international community in the face of atrocity crimes. By shifting the discourse from 'sovereignty as control' to 'sovereignty as responsibility', R2P places primary responsibility on states to protect their population from atrocity crimes and shifts this responsibility to the international community when the state is 'unable' or 'unwilling' to protect. However, after it was adopted by the United Nations General Assembly, R2P has not yet been a solution to ongoing humanitarian crises as evinced by the current cases mainly due to the political impasse at the United Nations Security Council. In this vein, this thesis explores the place of the 'intervention by invitation' (IvI) within the R2P framework as an aspect of prevention and/or timely action that can resolve the impasse. Building on state consent, the invited states assume the collective responsibility to protect if the UNSC fails to respond to the mass atrocity crimes. In view of this, the responsibility of the inviting and intervening states is intertwined in the three-pillar implementation strategy of R2P. As part of its Pillar I responsibilities, the state may request for military assistance in case of inability to protect the population and trigger Pillar II that is international assistance. Pursuant to the triggering of the responsibility of the international community, the intervening states may uphold the international community's Pillar II responsibility through 'preventive deployment'. In the event that the state is manifestly failing to protect its population and there arises a need for decisive action, when the Security Council fails to adopt a decision, such as for the authorisation of all necessary measures up to and including the use of force, based on the existing and applicable consent, the invited interveners can undertake the use of force in a 'timely and decisive' manner under Pillar III. Accordingly, to consider situations where an intervention is to take place, this thesis proposes a newly formulated test known as 'effective population protection legitimacy' (EPPL) in order to ensure its effective and right implementation. The applicability and feasibility of this test is analysed through the case of Yemen.

Military interventionUnited NationsUnited Nations Security Council+6
Haseenah Huurieyah Wan Roslı
Hacettepe University · Institute of Graduate Studies in Social Sciences
2019
00
Master'sOpen AccessEN

Koruma sorumluluğu çerçevesinde yeni zorluklar: Terörizm ve nüfusların korunması

In response to ongoing human rights violations, as well as the debates on humanitarian interventions, the International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty (ICISS) developed the notion of the Responsibility to Protect (R2P) in 2001 and it was unanimously adopted by the United Nations General Assembly in the 2005 World Summit. At the core of the R2P notion, lie the sovereignty as responsibility understanding, and the responsibility of the international community to protect populations when their states are unable or unwilling to do so. From 2006, to date, the United Nations Security Council has invoked R2P in more than 50 resolutions. Moreover, since 2009, the United Nations General Assembly has held nine informal interactive dialogues on R2P. Essentially, since the first introduction of R2P, UN member states are working to form consensus around it, as well as to narrow the gap between conceptual progress and preventive action. To date, R2P has found wide coverage in the International Relations literature, nevertheless, there are still underexplored aspects of the topic. In this vein, building its analysis on the observation that States are not the only actors who are responsible for mass atrocities, this thesis aims to make a contribution to the existing literature by focusing on non-state actors, and more precisely terrorist organizations, within the context of R2P and protection of populations. In the current era, together with technological progresses and globalization, non-state actors have become major challengers to states and the international system. In this regard, this thesis focuses on the international R2P response in situations wherein the perpetrators are non-state actors, and accordingly focuses on the two select cases of the Islamic State (ISIS) and Boko Haram within the context of the mass atrocity crimes that are grounds for invoking R2P action.

United NationsUnited Nations Security CouncilBoko Haram+5
Çağlar Açıkyıldız
Hacettepe University · Institute of Graduate Studies in Social Sciences
2018
00
Master'sOpen AccessEN

Yeni savaşlarda Jus ad Bellum ve Jus in Bello

The concept of warfare has been transforming since the end of the Cold War, and more recently following with the war on terror policy of the United States. This changing concept of warfare created contestations to norms as jus ad bellum and jus in bello. New wars did not totally transform the traditional wars, but it added new concepts and level of analysis to it. These new concepts and levels of analysis have created contestation areas in which meanings-in-use of jus ad bellum and jus in bello have been debated. As a result, the war on terror and cyber wars have appeared as a new domain for international law. The regulation of new wars with existing norms/laws have been quite challenging because of the different characteristics and tools of new wars. Not only, universal meanings of these norms have been challenged in this domain, but also existing conventions such as the Geneva Conventions and its Additional Protocol and the Charter of the United Nations have been able to contain new wars. Consequently, contestations and deliberations over jus ad bellum and jus in bello norms have appeared, creating an opportunity for reconstructing a universal meaning for these norms. In this vein, by examining different processes of policy-making of different actors in specific cases and revealing their differences in their claims of legitimacy for these conflicting ideas, this thesis examines the implications of the norms of the jus ad bellum and jus in bello in new wars.

ConceptsNormlarWar+5
Onur Gökçer
Hacettepe University · Institute of Graduate Studies in Social Sciences
2018
00

Other supervisors